Predictable Presents Are Overrated—26 Gift Ideas That Will Stand Out

This year, I’m on a mission to skip the predictable presents and lean into gifts that feel thoughtful, luxurious, and a little unexpected. Forget the typical last-minute candles or generic gift cards—this season, it’s about finding something that feels as special as the people you’re giving it to. Luxe gifting isn’t just about the price tag; it’s about selecting items that show a little extra consideration, something that feels indulgent but also unique.

Whether it’s a beautifully crafted cashmere set, an elegant fragrance from a niche brand, or an accessory with a timeless feel, these are gifts that stand out from the usual holiday shuffle. I’ve rounded up a list of ideas that range from understated opulence to practical elegance—presents that are just as exciting to give as they are to receive. Here are the luxe picks I’m eyeing that promise to bring a touch of sophistication to any holiday celebration.

Predictable: Generic Scented Candles

Luxe: Custom Fragrance Experience

I love a candle, but at this point, my apartment is filled with them because they’re such a common gift to receive. While I love a special, luxe candle, it’s becoming a bit cliché to open up on a big holiday. For this reason, I’m suggesting offering your loved one a custom fragrance experience. If they visit NYC often or live here, The Scent Bar and Olfactory offer incredible experiences for finding your signature scent, but you can find your local alternative or select a luxe fragrance for them that you know they’ll love.

Predictable: Gift Cards to Big Retailers

Luxe: Silk Pajamas

To be honest, when receiving a gift from someone who doesn’t know me well, a gift card can often be the best option because I know I’ll get exactly what I want, but if it’s someone close to me, it’s always an honor when they pick something out that’s a bit more thoughtful. A gift I’ve been giving for years is a luxe pajama or loungewear set because I just know that people are going to love it. It’s a no-fail way to make your friend or family member feel like a queen while getting ready for bed.

Predictable: Mugs With Generic Quotes

Luxe: Personalized Fine Jewelry

Mugs with generic quotes are the kind of gift that I expect to receive from a little brother or distant co-worker. At this point, my pantry is full in the mug department. I love how mugs can get customized to have a special, personalized touch, but fine jewelry looks even better when you add something to it that makes it specific to you. Be it a charm bracelet with some of their favorite things on it or their initial on a necklace encrusted in diamonds, they’ll fall in love with this gift idea instantly for sure.

Predictable: Basic Bath Sets

Luxe: High-End Throw Blanket

I’ve been gifted bath sets again and again, but some people just don’t like baths, and I’m one of them. However, if you want to give them something for their home that’s cozy and useful, a high-end throw blanket will always win. You could go with a classic option from Hermès or Loewe for the perfect finishing touch or try something new from one of their favorite designers. They and their guests will love this gift.

Predictable: Office Supplies

Luxe: Designer Coffee Table Book

Pens, notebooks, etc., can wait for the New Year. Let’s forget the traditional office supplies when it comes to the gift-giving season. Instead, I think a designer coffee table book is something that the recipient can cherish in their office or home and bring some joy to their everyday.

Predictable: Fruit Baskets

Luxe: An It Bag

Fruit baskets should come from a client you rarely speak to, but for someone you’re close with, I have a different kind of basket in mind. A luxury It bag is going to be something they’ll reach for again and again no matter what time of year. Gifting it is just the best possible way to make someone happy and can easily define their sense of style that year.

Predictable: Tacky Key Chains

Luxe: Statement Home Décor Piece

I love a luxe key chain, but I’ve also seen a lot of license plate or touristy ones, and enough is enough. However, a statement home décor piece adds a personal and stylish touch to a loved one’s space, making it feel unique and inviting. It’s a lasting gift that blends beauty and functionality, serving as a daily reminder of your thoughtfulness.